West Cape May Vacation Rentals
A CHARMING TOWN BY THE SEA
Famous for it’s quirky festivals, like the Lima Bean or Strawberry Festival, West Cape May is a charming little town by the sea and just a short stroll from historic Cape May! West Cape May's history goes back to the time of the Lenape Indians and several of the historic buildings date back to the Colonial period. The area has a rich agricultural history which is home to local farms such as Beach Plum Farm and Willow Creek Winery.
45 properties available
Welcome to P & J Carriage House! A custom built garage apartment constructed in 2018 where a single barn once stood and is available as a vacation rental. This 2 bedroom, 1 bath home sleeps up to 6 guests comfortably. There is a king bed in the master and a queen bed in the second bedroom. The sofa sleeper has a queen sized mattress. The bathroom h
102 Second Avenue
West Cape May
2
bedrooms
1
baths
6
guests
Welcome to Casa del Sol in beautiful West Cape May. Settle into this comfortable 3-bedroom rental property complete with a screened in porch, front porch, a cozy TV room, and open living and kitchen area with seating for 6 at the dining table. Nearby attractions include Willow Creek Winery and Beach Plum Farms. Down the road, Sunset Beach with the
630 Second Avenue
West Cape May
3
bedrooms
2
baths
6
guests
"Welcome to “Lavendar Dreams By The Sea” in West Cape May. Built in 1857, this historic home includes 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Enjoy sitting on the front porch in the rocking chairs overlooking Broadway, updated amenities throughout the home and is pet friendly with a fenced in yard.
BEDROOMS: SECOND FLOOR: Bedroom 1- Queen Bed, Bedroom 2 - 2
423 Broadway
West Cape May
4
bedrooms
2
baths
10
guests
The Upper West Side in West Cape May! This well-maintained apartment on Fourth Ave. features a screened porch, living area, eat-in kitchen and bathroom with a walk-in shower. The bedroom has two dressers and is built for comfort. Bike to Cape May and the beach.
108 Fourth Ave
West Cape May
1
bedrooms
1
baths
4
guests
Welcome to your exquisite new getaway at 211 Third Ave, West Cape May, NJ! This beautiful newly constructed rental property showcases exceptional craftsmanship and timeless finishes, providing a luxurious retreat near the charming downtown area of Cape May.
Step inside to discover an amazing great room and a chef\'s kitchen that features stunning
211 Third Avenue
West Cape May
4
bedrooms
4
baths
12
guests
Welcome to Sea Pines Cottage in charming West Cape May! This 2-bedroom, 1-bathoom retreat is just one mile to the gorgeous Cape May beaches and is situated on a large private lot with a brand-new pool, wonderful tree cover, patio and deck.
Wake to sun streaming into the breakfast nook, relax in the charming living room, and cook in the well-appoi
406 Fourth Ave
West Cape May
2
bedrooms
1
baths
6
guests
Pool
Welcome to the ultimate West Cape May retreat at 414-416 Broadway. This building is split into two mirror-image units, and is now available as a whole house rental for large groups. This unique setup offers 8 total bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms, allowing your group to enjoy the best of West Cape May together while maintaining the privacy of two sep
414 and 416 Broadway
West Cape May
8
bedrooms
4
baths
15
guests
DOG FRIENDLY IN WEST CAPE MAY!
Welcome to 235 A Fourth Avenue in West Cape May. Located on the second block of Fourth Avenue sits this one-story cedar sided beach bungalow that includes three bedrooms and two full bathrooms.
BEDROOMS: BEDROOM 1 (Primary Suite): queen size bed. BEDROOM 2: queen size bed. BEDROOM 3: full size bed. LIVING ARE
235 A Fourth Avenue
West Cape May
3
bedrooms
2
baths
8
guests
Nestled on the edge of the Nature Conservancy land with amazing views of the meadows, lighthouse and ocean this lovely raised two story home is a Birder s delight. Home features great room with french doors to deck, 5 bedrooms, den, 3 full baths, living room, eat in kitchen, sunroom with wood burning stove, screened porch and gated in-ground pool.
324 First Avenue
West Cape May
5
bedrooms
3
baths
10
guests
Pool
Welcome to 414 Broadway, a stunning property situated in the heart of charming West Cape May. This spacious four bedroom, two bathroom home offers a perfect blend of Victorian character and modern comfort, putting you just steps away from local favorites like Bella Vida Cafe, Westside Market, and Panico\'s Bistro. Linens (blankets, sheets, and bat
414 Broadway
West Cape May
4
bedrooms
2
baths
7
guests
Welcome to “Sea La Vie” at 739 Broadway, Unit 1, West Cape May! This 2 story, 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath luxury home features a private entrance and a prime corner location at Broadway and Central perfect for enjoying all that West Cape May has to offer.
BEDROOMS AND BATHROOMS:
Bedroom 1 & Bathroom 1 (Second Floor): Spacious master suite with private b
739 Broadway
West Cape May
3
bedrooms
2
baths
1
Half baths
6
guests
Welcome to Holly Cottage at Shunpike Pond where Williamsburg meets Cape May. The cottage gets it\'s name from the huge holly tree in the front yard. Holly Cottage overlooks the famous birding destination "Shunpike Pond." A park like setting with bird views for your enjoyment. The owners love of Williamsburg shows with touches of antiques blended
751 Stimpson Lane
West Cape May
3
bedrooms
1
baths
1
Half baths
6
guests
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.
Copyright © 2026 • Coastline Realty
All Rights Reserved.